Shop Authentic Homemade Italian Cookies Online | Toni’s Own Cookies
Browse our selection of freshly baked Italian cookies, including our signature anisette cookies, and bring tradition to your table.
Want to view our Platters or Gluten Free Products?
Anisette Cookies
Our signature anisette cookies feature a soft, cake-like center with a delicate anise flavor, topped with creamy white icing and colorful nonpareils sprinkles. Made from a traditional, authentic family recipe, these timeless treats are the perfect blend of flavor and nostalgia.
Butter Spritz Cookies
Our traditional Italian butter spritz cookies are crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, and bursting with flavor. Featuring five delightful varieties, pistachio, almond, strawberry, lemon, and orange, each cookie is crafted with real butter for an authentic and irresistible taste experience.
Champagne Cookies
Toni's Champagne Cookies are light, soft, and subtly sweet with a refreshing lemon flavor. Decorated with colorful jimmies for an extra touch of sweetness and vibrant appeal, these classic Italian treats are perfect for any celebration.
Cocoa Bliss Cookies
Similar to our Flag Cookie, Toni's Coca Bliss Cookie melts in your mouth with its light, subtly sweet texture and rich fudge flavor. Covered in chocolate jimmies, it’s a decadent treat that’s impossible to resist.
Fig Cuccidati Cookies
Toni's Fig Cuccidati Cookies feature soft, sweet dough filled with a rich fig and spice blend. Topped with a drizzled flavored glaze, these traditional Italian treats deliver a perfect balance of sweetness and warmth in every bite.
Ginger Drop Cookies
Experience the cozy flavors of the season with Toni's Ginger Drop Cookies. Made with spicy ginger, sweet molasses, and aromatic spices, these soft delights are perfect for holiday celebrations. Treat yourself or share the warmth with loved ones!
Lemon Burst Cookies
Indulge in the zesty goodness of Toni's Lemon Burst Cookies. Soft and cake-like, these treats are covered in creamy white icing with sprinkles and made with 100% pure lemon oil for an unforgettable citrus flavor. Truly a lemon lover’s dream!
Raspberry Cuccidati Cookies
Toni's Raspberry Cuccidati Cookies are a twist on the classic Sicilian treat. These soft dough delights, filled with a delicate raspberry center and topped with a drizzled glaze, live up to the name "lovely bracelet" with their exquisite taste and charm.
S Cookies
Toni's Sicilian S Cookies are a perfect blend of subtle sweetness and dunkable goodness. These vanilla-flavored, biscuit-like cookies are ideal for enjoying with coffee, tea, or on their own as a satisfying treat.
Sesame Cookies
Our authentic Sesame Cookies are golden brown with a crisp exterior and a light, subtly sweet interior. These handmade Italian treats are a must-have for any occasion and sure to please any crowd.
Vanilla Cookies
Toni's Vanilla Cookies are smooth, cake-like delights topped with a light glaze and infused with rich vanilla flavor. A perfect choice for those who love a classic, silky-smooth treat!
Sweet Dough Gift Certificate
Share the love of Toni's Own with a Sweet Dough Gift Certificate. Perfect for any occasion, this e-gift lets recipients choose their favorite Italian cookies to enjoy when they want. A delicious way to spread joy!
2lb Anisette Cookie Platter
Savor the authentic taste of tradition with Toni's 2lb Anisette Cookie Platter. Featuring soft, cake-like cookies with a mild anise flavor, creamy white icing, and colorful sprinkles, this platter is perfect for gatherings, holidays, or as a gift for Italian cookie lovers.
2lb Sesame Cookie Platter
A sure crowd-pleaser, Toni's 2lb Sesame Cookie Platter offers golden brown cookies with a crisp exterior and subtly sweet, flavorful inside. Perfectly crafted for any celebration, these handmade Italian treats will leave your guests impressed.
2lb Champagne Cookie Platter
Delight in the vibrant flavors of Toni's 2lb Champagne Cookie Platter. These light, lemony "flag cookies" are surrounded by colorful jimmies, adding sweetness and visual appeal to your table. Perfect for celebrations or indulgence!
2lb Cocoa Bliss Cookie Platter
Treat yourself to Toni's 2lb Cocoa Bliss Cookie Platter. These light, subtly sweet cookies feature a fudge flavor enriched with chocolate jimmies. A luxurious addition to any event or dessert table.
2lb Vanilla Cookie Platter
Enjoy the classic taste of Toni's 2lb Vanilla Cookie Platter. With cake-like centers, light vanilla glaze, and a silky-smooth texture, these cookies are a timeless choice for gatherings or gifts.
2lb Lemon Burst Cookie Platter
Zest up your celebrations with Toni's 2lb Lemon Burst Cookie Platter. Made with 100% pure lemon oil and topped with creamy icing and sprinkles, these cookies deliver a burst of vibrant citrus flavor in every bite.
2lb Half Anise & Half Lemon Cookie Platter
Can’t decide? Toni's 2lb Half Anise, Half Lemon Cookie Platter brings the best of both worlds with the mild licorice flavor of anisette and the zesty brightness of lemon cookies. A perfect balance for every taste!
2lb Sesame, Champagne & Cocoa Bliss Cookie Platter (Combo)
Experience variety with Toni's 2lb Combo Platter, featuring a delightful mix of sesame, champagne, and cocoa bliss cookies. Perfect for sharing, this platter ensures there’s something for everyone at your gathering.
Gluten Free Anisette Cookies - (4 10oz Packs)
Enjoy the timeless taste of anisette in a gluten-free version! Toni's Own Gluten-Free Anisette Cookies are soft, flavorful, and crafted in a nut-free facility, delivering the same classic experience as the original recipe.
Gluten Free Lemon Burst Cookies (4 10oz Packs)
Experience the zesty flavor of lemons in Toni's Own Gluten-Free Lemon Burst Cookies. Made with the same authentic lemon oil and cake-like texture, this gluten-free treat brings the best of the original without the gluten.
Get in Touch
Send us a message using the form below.